Time Heist premieres in:

Wednesday, 6 May 2009

Doctor Who - Rose, The Next Doctor & Marriage - My Reactions


This post is in reaction to this one yesterday, you may like to read it first to understand what I am talking about.

So we have The Other Doctor and Rose Smith, lets look into this first.

What Other Doctors do we know of? Theres the meta-crisis Doctor, generally referred to as 10.5, who we assume they mean, but who else could it be? How about Matt Smith? He is defiantly an Other Doctor, but would he be meeting Rose Tyler?

Next we have Rose Smith, with there only being one Rose in Doctor Who, unless you count that Yorkshire Terrier, we assume its Rose Tyler, but married? What other Smiths are there? Theres Mickey/Ricky Smith, but Noel Clarke has walked away from the series to persue an already successful movie career. Then there is Sarah Jane Smith and her adopted son Luke Smith, so a same sex marridge to Sarah Jane? Someone who is almost an OAP? I think not, I can't see Luke going there either. So it has to be the meta-crisis Doctor, who uses the name John Smith when it suits!

So does Rose marry 10.5? Well, she loved the real Doctor, and this is the closest she will ever get to him, but its still not him! But can Rose be pregnant with 10.5s child too? I have to admit this would be very Russell T Davies!

This is how I'd end the series - 10.5 is with Rose, who is close to having their baby. Meanwhile the Doctor is going to regenerate, but he needs his energy used to create 10.5 back, so against his will, it returns, and 10.5 dies. Not a dry eye in the house, this is very Russell T Davies too!

Then - The baby is born and grows up hating the Doctor, who has caused him to grow up without a father. He has 10.5s TARDIS and is a genius of course. He reaches say 25, and finds a way back to our dimension in his TARDIS, and through the power of time-travel, this can arrive in season 5 or 6! Compared with the Doctors child, the Master is a pussy! And the current doctor has some real trouble coming!

Of course, it could all be fanwank, and the email I recieved was rubbish, who knows?

13 comments :

Otherson said...

I personally think bringing Rose back and having a 10.5 was all a huge, silly mistake in the first place. So, I hope the whole thing is not going to happen and Other Doctor/Rose Smith is a just a rumor.

However, if it's true, then your guess is actually pretty good.

Deka Black said...

Only waiting show us the true response.

question said...

There is definitely a possibility that 10.5 is a John Smith. 10.5 has a normal human life-span, so if he ages like a human is logical for him to create new identity and try to fit in with rest of the world.
But i wouldn't want for him to die, it would be cool if he could pop out durning series five, as a bad guy perhaps....But if Moffat wants to start with a clean slate, and RTD wants to tie up all loose ends from his previous stories...Then i'm afraid 10.5 is doomed :P

alyasne said...

Noooo! 10.5 and Rose have to live happily ever after! I'm gonna be so mad at RTD if he ruins Rose's happy life! Why can't they just let us assume 10.5 and Rose are happy in their little world and just leave that story closed since Tennant will be gone? They don't have to bring it up...just move on with other stories. I dunno I guess I'm just a stereotypical Doctor/Rose lover and want 10.5 and Rose to be happy. I'm already sad enough Tennant's leaving =/

Combom said...

RTD wants tears though, 10.5 has to go!

pj said...

You had me up until you killed 10.5. I think RTD will gets his tears when Ten regeneratesm he doesn't need to add to the trauma or worse, steal the Doctor's thunder by killing 10.5. Rather, I think 10.5 will stand as a symbol of hope for viewers that DT may return in some capacity someday, so a nice scene of Rose and Smith happily ever after would be a nice touch after the sadness of the loss of Ten.

Laura said...

Everything you said it is very RTD, I admit that, but the whole thing reads like a soap opera plot, lol. Again, very RTD!

I'm with Otherson and I hope the whole thing is just a rumor.

Trey Lane's not really on Blogspot said...

10.5 doesn't have a TARDIS, silly.

also, that first paragraph was some of the most nonsensical space-wastage ever.

love the blog tho...

Combom said...

nonsensical space wastage - hmm, word invention? :) :) :)

TARDIS? oh yes he does, watch this scene...

http://lifetheuniverseandcombom.blogspot.com/2008/11/doctor-who-journeys-end-alternate.html

:)

morgaine-nicely said...

Well...I really DONT want them to kill off 10.5...but....knowing Rusty, he'd do something like that just to tick us all off...and believe me i WILL be mad if he does.....BUT I also did read that David said in an interview that he cried when he read the final script...soo....I guess we'll just have to wait and see dangit. I am very curious about this filming scene coming up though :)

Kelsey said...

10.5 didn't get a TARDIS guys. Just for the record.

pcjonathan said...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FcqdojFsuNo

yolor said...

Actually, it was originally meant to be that the 10th doctor was to give 10.5 a part of the TARDIS (So that it would grow in to another, like coral). However, this scene was cut.